It is simply fact to say that wood is a versatile and essential material that has been used for construction, furniture making, and other purposes for years. Two main types of wood are commonly used: softwood and hardwood. While both have their own unique properties and applications, there are some key differences between the two.

That is what we will be explaining in this article.

Softwoods Explained

pine wood for diy

Pine

spruce wood

Spruce

cedar wood

cedar

Softwood is sourced from all across the world and accounts for about 80% of the production of all timber. The main suppliers are North America, Russia, China and the Scandinavian countries. Softwood is mainly used in the construction industry as a structural timber and often as a finishing timber.

When you look through any DIY store or builders you should notice that the majority of wood on sale will be softwood. That is because it is cheaper to buy and easier to work with. You can easily recognise it as the softwood is a light colour with a fairly loose grain.

It comes from coniferous trees such as pine, spruce, and fir, is recognisable by its needle-like leaves. Its lighter weight and less dense structure, compared to hardwood, make it an ideal choice for projects that demand flexibility and lightweight construction.

Characteristics

  • Lightweight: Softwood has a light weight and that makes it easier to transport, handle, and use during woodworking tasks.
  • Flexibility: It is less dense than hardwood and that allows for easier bending and shaping, making it suitable for projects that require curved or contoured forms.
  • Workability: Ask any woodworker and they will tell you that it is generally easier to saw, drill, and sand, making it a popular choice for beginners and hobbyists.
  • Cost-effectiveness: Softwood is often more readily available and less expensive than hardwood, making it a budget-friendly option.

Main Applications

  • Construction: Because it is light and easy to work with it is the preferred choice for framing, sheathing, and other structural components in buildings.
  • Furniture Making: Regularly used for making furniture frames, along with plywood, and other components where lightweight construction is desired.
  • DIY Projects: Softwood's versatility and affordability make it a popular choice for DIY projects, from simple shelves and cabinets to birdhouses and other woodworking jobs.

Hardwoods Explained

oak wood

Oak

maple wood

Maple

mahogany wood

Mahogany

Hardwood is also sourced from all across the world and accounts for about 20% of the production of all timber. The main suppliers are China North America, India, Brazil and Canada. Hardwood is used to make furniture, boats, veneers, flooring and also used in the construction industry.

Hardwoods are always a dark colour and they have a tight and more dense looking grain. It will last longer than softwoods but are harder to saw, harder to drill through and much harder to screw into. On average you will find that hardwoods are 3-4 times the price of a similar piece of softwood.

Hardwood, comes from deciduous trees like oak, maple, and birch. They are recognised by their broad leaves that change color in the fall. Its heavier weight and denser structure compared to softwood result in greater strength, durability, and resistance to warping and cracking. Additionally, hardwood is known for its aesthetic appeal, with rich grains and textures that enhance the visual appeal of woodworking projects.

Characteristics

  • Strength and Durability: It has a denser structure that makes it significantly stronger and more durable than softwood, making it ideal for projects that require heavy-duty construction and long-lasting performance
  • Resistance to Warping and Cracking: It has an inherent stability and resistance to moisture fluctuations make it less prone to warping and cracking, ensuring the longevity of woodworking projects..
  • Aesthetic Appeal: It has rich grains and textures, and along with its ability to take stains and finishes, make it the preferred choice for high-end furniture, cabinetry, and flooring, where both functionality and aesthetics are paramount.

Main Applications

  • High Quality Furniture Making: Its strength, durability, and aesthetic appeal make it the preferred choice for crafting high-quality furniture, such as dining tables, chairs, and cabinets.
  • Flooring: It is very resistant to wear and tear. That along with its elegance and ability to enhance the ambiance of a space, make it a popular choice for flooring in homes, offices, and other establishments.
  • Musical Instruments: It has very good acoustic properties. That makes it one of the best materials for crafting various musical instruments, including guitars, violins, and pianos.

Softwoods vs Hardwoods Compared

The obvious answer is that softwoods are soft and hardwoods are hard. As a general rule that is true, however like most general rules, there are a few softwoods that are actually harder than hardwoods.as an example the wood from a Yew tree is harder then many hardwoods. Likewise the Balsa tree is a hardwood tree but softer than many softwoods.

Hardwoods grow much slower than softwoods and simply because of that, the wood is denser or thicker. That makes hardwood stronger and harder to cut or drill through.

Hardwoods

  • Comes from angiosperm trees that are not monocots and known as deciduous trees such as oak, ash, walnut, maple, beech teak and mahogany
  • Tends to be more expensive to buy
  • Almost always harder, stronger and durable
  • They have a dark colour
  • They are heavy and easier to repair
  • They have a tight close grain
  • They have a low sap
  • These last longer than softwood
  • More fire resistant

Softwoods

  • Comes from gymnosperm trees known as evergreen trees and tend to have needles and cones such as fir, spruce, pine, cedar and redwood
  • Softwoods tend to be cheaper to buy than hardwoods
  • Will generally speaking be softer than hardwoods
  • They have a light colour
  • They are light
  • They have a loose grain
  • They have a high sap
  • Softwood doesn't last as long as hardwood
  • Poor fire resistance

The video below explains this difference really well. It also contains an explanation of the Janka Hardness Test, a recognised method of defining exactly how hard a wood is.

Softwoods vs Hardwoods - Density

Softwood Density (lbs per square foot)

Cedar 23

Douglas Fir 33

Juniper 35

Pine 22-35

Redwood 28-55

Spruce 25-44

Yew 42

Hardwood Density (lbs per square foot)

Alder 26-42

Aspen 26

Balsa 7-9

Beech 32-56

Hickory 37-58

Magnolia 35

Mahogany 31-53

Oak 37-56

Poplar 22-31

Teak 41-61

Walnut 40-43

As a general rule you can see that hardwoods are more dense than softwoods with the odd exception.

Choosing the Right Wood for Your Project: Softwood vs Hardwood

The choice between softwood and hardwood depends on the specific requirements and desired outcomes of your project. Consider these factors when making your decision:

  • Project Type: Softwood is suitable for lightweight construction and simple projects, while hardwood is better suited for heavy-duty applications, fine furniture making, and flooring.
  • Budget: Softwood is less expensive than hardwood, making it a budget-friendly option.
  • Desired Aesthetic: Hardwood offers a more refined and elegant appearance compared to softwood.
  • Skill Level: Softwood is easier to work with, making it a good choice for beginners, while hardwood requires more experience and skill. It is always best to start as a beginner using soft woods until your skills improve.

Other Considerations

  • Environmental Impact: Consider the sustainability practices of the timber industry and opt for wood sourced from responsibly managed forests. Most suppliers will have this information visible.
  • Local Availability: Check the availability of different wood species in your region to minimise transportation costs and environmental impact. again most good manufacturers do this on our behalf.
  • Maintenance Requirements: Hardwood may require more maintenance, such as regular polishing and sealing, to maintain its appearance.

By carefully considering these factors and additional considerations, you can make an informed decision about whether softwood or hardwood is the right choice for your next project. Remember, the key lies in understanding the unique properties of each type of wood and matching them to the specific needs and requirements of your woodworking endeavor.

Resources for further reading

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}